Dealing Antique Quilts
Cindy Rennels of Cindy's Antique Quilts in Clinton, Oklahoma. Photo courtesy of Cindy Rennels.
Jane Lury, owner of New York-based Labors of Love, views an old quilt with a customer. Photo courtesy of Jane Lury.
Suzanne Cude of Apples of Gold in San Antonio, Texas.
Virtually every major quilt or antique show across the country features several antique quilt dealers. If you’re like me, you’ll stand in front of these booths and do your best to keep from drooling.
With fabulous old quilts showing remarkable workmanship, unique designs, unusual color combinations, and vintage fabrics lining the walls of their spaces, the antique quilt vendors always have the most appealing displays. I wish I could buy everything I see, and I always wonder about the dealers themselves.
How did they get involved with antique quilts? How has their business changed over the years? And perhaps—most importantly—how they can bear to part with their wares?
Cindy Rennels, who owns Cindy’s Antique Quilts in Clinton, Oklahoma, didn’t grow up with quilts or come from a sewing family. In the mid-1980s, when a friend (who was already knowledgeable about quilts) started buying on a local radio “swap shop” program, Cindy started doing the same. Interest turned to fascination. She soon became a full-fledged collector, advertising in area trade papers, visiting private homes, and attending auctions.
As her collection grew, she realized that she needed to pare down, and she began selling some of her quilts at antique shows and craft fairs. Finally, she gave up her “day job” with her family’s livestock auction business and became a full time dealer.
Cindy’s quilt knowledge has evolved through the years, and she now attends shows all across the country, handling a wide variety of quilts. She always makes a special effort to learn as much as possible about the provenance of her quilts, as that is of great importance to her clientele.
Since her home base is in the Midwest, her collection tends to contain more quilts from the 1930s, but her buying trips across the country help fill in the void by adding quilts from the 1830s to the 1900s. Cindy feels that the market for quilts in the mid-price range ($400 to $800) is fairly soft in the current economy, but more expensive quilts ($1000 to $5000 and up) continue to sell well.
“I always have ‘keepers’—quilts that I don’t want to sell. I do collect patriotic quilts, chintz, and western-theme quilts among others,” Cindy says. “I may bring something special out of my personal collection and I’ll offer it for sale at a show, as these may be the quilts that other collectors are also drawn to. Often those quilts will sell and then I’ll say to myself, ‘I’m going to miss that quilt, but I know the buyer will enjoy it also!’ ”
Labors of Love is the name of Jane Lury’s antique quilt business. Jane works as a psychologist in New York City. Selling antique quilts, according to her partner, David, “is a weekend hobby that has gotten totally out of hand.”
In the 1980s, while on a trip to Oregon, Jane saw a quilt for sale in an antique store and bought it. When she returned to New York, she visited a few of the stores that had quilts in the city. Then, while driving across the country the next year, she found and bought more. She amassed such a quantity that she decided she needed to reduce her collection.
When she easily sold those quilts at an auction, she decided to continue buying. “I loved the quilts, but I got into the business by pecking at it,” Jane laughs. Now she and David attend about nine major quilt festivals and textile events annually, including shows in Tokyo and France.
“Over the past 25 years, my business has gone through good times and bad times, although I’ve seen little change during the current recession. Quilts are comfort items, and comforting things are valued in hard times,” Jane explains. “The major difference over the past decade is that I now sell mostly expensive quilts. The ones priced under $1000 don’t sell as well, except overseas.”
When asked if she has a hard time parting with her quilts, Jane is quick to respond: “My home is bedecked with quilts! I try not to sell the ones that really move me.”
Antique dealer Suzanne Cude, owner of Apples of Gold in San Antonio, Texas, added fine old quilts to her inventory in 1978. She credits Jonathan Holstein’s 1971 exhibition of quilts at the Whitney Museum of American Art in New York as being the watershed event that made people not only recognize the beauty and artistic merit of quilts, but want to collect them as well. Though not a quilter herself, Suzanne has sewn for years and has long been interested in textiles of all sorts.
The main difference that Suzanne has seen in the antique quilt business through the years has been the knowledge level of her customers. Today’s quilt buyers are extremely well-informed. Like Cindy and Jane, Suzanne has seen the mid-range quilt market slow down, while expensive quilts still readily sell.
“True collectors are always out there,” she says. “If you have something really special, they will buy it.” As might be expected, it is not as easy to find truly remarkable old quilts as it once was, although Suzanne says you just never know when something amazing is going to show up. She recently had someone bring in a magnificent quilt to her shop—it literally walked in her door.
“I have quilts hanging in every room of my house, and sometimes I’ll even decorate a room around a particular quilt,” says Suzanne. “I’ve reached that point in life where I’m starting to downsize though, and I’m beginning to let some of them go. Not long ago I sold one of my favorites—an 1850s red chintz—and I started crying as I wrote up the ticket. The lady who bought it promised me she would give it a good home!”
Click here to return to top.
Column 110: Quilters Helping Quilters
Column 109: Community Cookbooks and Fundraiser Quilts—Parallel Histories
Column 108: Quilting to Freedom
Column 107: National Quilting Day
Column 106: The Airing of the Quilts
Column 105: A Call for a National Juneteenth Commemorative Quilt
Column 104: Dominoes
Column 103: 1936 Texas Centennial Bluebonnet Quilt
Column 102: Helen Blackstone, A Texas Quilter
Column 101: Montana CattleWomen Anniversary Brand Quilt
Column 100: 100th Suzy's Fancy Column!
Column 99: Montana Stockgrowers Anniversary Brand Quilt
Column 98: The Tobacco Sack Connection
Column 97: Meet the Sisters Who Are State Fair Quilting Queens
Column 96: The connection between fairs and quilts.
Column 95: Her Mother Pieced Quilts
Column 94: Rebecca Barker’s Quiltscapes
Column 93: The Thread and Thimble Club Mystery
Column 92: The Ballerina Quilter
Column 91: Grandmother's Flower Garden Comes Alive at Texas Quilt Museum
Column 90: Leitmotif for a Lifelong Love Affair
Column 89: Quilting in The Bahamas
Column 88: Joan of Arc: A Quilter's Inspiration
Column 87: Home Demonstration Clubs and Quilting
Column 86: Linzi Upton and the Quilted Yurt
Column 85: A Bounty of Quilts
Column 84: Desert Trader
Column 83: Quilts and the Women’s Liberation Movement
Column 82: Replicating the Past: Reproduction Fabrics for Today’s Quilts
Column 81: Why So Many Quilt Shops in Bozeman, Montana?
Column 80: Southeastern Quilt and Textile Museum
Column 79: 54 Tons of Quilt
Column 78: Ollie Steele Burden’s Quilt Blocks
Column 77: Quilting with AMD
Column 76: Maverick Quilts and Cowgirls
Column 75: The Modern Quilt Guild—Cyberculture Quilting Ramps Up
Column 74: The Membership Quilt—Czech Quilting in Texas
Column 73: Maximum Security Quilts
Column 72: Author: Terri Thayer
Column 71: The Christmas Quilt
Column 70: New Mexico Centennial Quilt
Column 69: Scrub Quilts
Column 68: “Think Pink” Quilt Raises Funds for Rare Cancer Research
Column 67: Righting Old Wrongs.
Column 66: 100 Years, 100 Quilts - More on the Arizona Centennial.
Column 65: Arizona Centennial Quilt Project
Column 64: Capt. John Files Tom’s Family Tree
Column 63: The Fat Quarters
Column 62: Quilt Fiction Author: Clare O’Donohue
Column 61: Louisiana Bicentennial Quilt
Column 60: The Camo Quilt Project.
Column 59: Thread Wit
Column 58: Ralli Quilts
Column 57: Preschool Quilters
Column 56: The Story Quilt
Column 55: Red and Green Quilts
Column 54: On the Trail
Column 53: Quilt Trail Gathering
Column 52: True Confessions: First Quilt
Column 51: Quilted Pages
Column 50: Doll Quilts
Column 49: More Than a Quilt Shop
Column 48: Las Colchas of the Texas-Mexico Border
Column 47: Literary Gifts
Column 46: A Different Way of Seeing
Column 45: Sampling
Column 44: Hen and Chicks
Column 43: A Star Studied Event
Column 42: Shoo Fly Pattern
Column 41: Awareness Quilts
Column 40: Tivaevae
Column 39: UnOILed UnspOILed Coast Quilt Project
Column 38: Katrina Recovery Quilts
Column 37: Quilted Vermont
Column 36: The Labyrinth Quilt—A Meditative Endeavor
See other archived columns here